Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Chad Holley Case: The Feds May Be Stepping In

By: Eric J. Davis




Yesterday, Congressman Al Green announced that he is calling on the United States Department of Justice to step in and investigate the beating of Chad Holly by several Houston Police Officers. As a defense attorney, I have seen less egregious cases prosecuted by Federal prosecutors. In this case, Federal Prosecution might shed more light on this situation and will certainly send the signal to other police officers that such conduct will be dealt with seriously. Thanks Al Green for stepping up. (Click on his photo to see a video of the press conference).


But with conduct so egregious and clearly portrayed on the tape, I still question the DA's decision to keep the tape from public disclosure. Clearly, withholding the tape from the F.B.I. and other law enforcement agencies impairs their ability to assess the situation and determine whether or not they want to pursue charges. Is the DA's Office sending the signal to officers that "we'll take care of you, even when you get caught doing wrong"? Why were these officers given favorable treatment? The Feds routinely are allowed to review other cases and determine whether or not they want to pursue charges. Why were they only charged with a misdemeanor? Most of the time when two or more people commit a crime together they are charged with engaging in organized crime. Is the DA saying it's not too bad to beat up young black men if they make you chase them? I think she is.

Saturday, February 5, 2011

Police Brutality that Rivals Rodney King - But This Time Its a Juvenile Beaten

By: Eric J. Davis
I hear clients all the time saying they are beaten by the Police when they are arrested. Usually, we have no proof and the Harris County DA's office is unsympathetic when we have no proof. Their complaints are never SUSTAINED! So here is a case where there was proof and the DA blocked release of the tape. In fact, the suspect was still convicted. The officers have yet to be tried and are still employed by the Houston Police Department. But check this video out -it rivals the Rodney King video (Click on the Photo to see the video).

Sad thing is that the officers were only charged with misdemeanor Official Oppression. They could have all at least been charged with the felony offense of engaging in organized crime (youth who cooperate with each other and break in cars are charged with that felony). The thing that surprises me is that the other officers are saying nothing as the beating occurs. No one says stop. No one says let up. No one says he has had enough. And after it was all said and done, no one said anything. They all joined in.... Is this acceptable behavior for officers in our city while on patrol? This all happened so spontaneously. It does not appear that the officers discussed it. But yet they quickly joined in and beat an unarmed, defenseless teenager who was in a surrender position. Such anger and hatred... protecting and serving? If the DA's Office is refusing to take any real action after viewing the tapes, then maybe the United States Attorney's Office will see it and be outraged enough to take action.

"I freed a thousand slaves I could have freed a thousand more if only they knew they were slaves."

- Harriet Tubman